Australia Questions Malaysia over Deportation
By Rod McGuirk 18 February 2013
CANBERRA, Australia — Australia has demanded an explanation from Malaysia for why it turned away an Australian senator from his fact-finding mission to investigate the Southeast Asian country’s electoral system ahead of elections due within months, the prime minister said on Sunday.
Nick Xenophon, an independent South Australia state senator, returned from Malaysia on Sunday saying he had been deported on the orders of the “highest levels” of the Malaysian government for his support of democracy reformers.
He told reporters on arrival at Melbourne International Airport after an 8-hour flight that he had become the first Australian lawmaker ever to be deported from any country when he was turned away by on authorities on arrival at Kuala Lumpur on Saturday.
Prime Minister Julia Gillard revealed that her government made “immediate and strenuous representations” for Xenophon to be allowed to stay in Malaysia.
“I was surprised and disappointed to see the treatment of Senator Xenophon yesterday,” Gillard told reporters.
“Clearly we didn’t succeed in getting the agreement of the Malaysian government for him to remain in Malaysia. We will continue to pursue this issue with the Malaysian government,” she added.
Xenophon blamed his support for the Malaysian democracy reform group Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections, known as Bersih, for the shock decision to turn him away.
“I understand the decision to deport me came from the highest levels of the Malaysian government,” Xenophon said.
“I was told I was being deported under a certain section of the Immigration Act which basically relates to being a security risk, but it seems the only risk I am is to embarrassing the Malaysia government because of my advocacy for clean elections in Malaysia,” he added.
Xenophon said it was up to Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak to say whether he had ordered the deportation.
Xenophon had planned to meet with Malaysian opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim, a Cabinet minister, electoral officials and political activists to discuss transparency issues for national elections that must be held by the end of June.
Hisan Hamzah, the police chief of Malaysia’s central Selangor state, said Xenophon was taken into custody when he arrived at the airport early Saturday and denied entry “for security reasons.”
Xenophon was detained in an interrogation area of the airport until he was put on a plane to Melbourne on Saturday night.
Immigration Director Gen Alias Ahmad said in a government-issued statement that Xenophon was barred because he was at a banned Kuala Lumpur demonstration last year. The rally was organized by Bersih.
“Malaysia is a free and democratic country, but no one is above the law,” the statement said.
“Authorities will take the appropriate action against any individual deemed to have violated national laws.”
Xenophon, a former lawyer, said he was considering appealing his deportation order in the Malaysian courts. He would have to testify in such a court case via a video link because he was banned from entering Malaysia indefinitely.
Xenophon said the visit planned by him and three parliamentary colleagues was intended to be low-key event which would have attracted little media attention had it gone ahead.
“You need to ask the question: what does the Malaysian government have to fear by having an open and robust scrutiny of their electoral processes?” he said.
“If the Malaysian government thought that they were doing the smart thing, I think it’s spectacularly backfired on them,” he added.
Xenophon visited Kuala Lumpur last April as a foreign observer at a rally where police used tear gas to disperse tens of thousands of Malaysians who demanded sweeping changes to electoral policies that they say are manipulated to favor Razak’s long-ruling coalition.
He subsequently said the crackdown on the rally raised “serious questions over how authoritarian” the country appeared to be.
Anwar called Xenophon’s detention “a gross abuse of power,” while Lim Chee Wee, president of the Malaysian Bar, which comprises more than 12,000 lawyers, said it was “shameful” and “absurd,” adding that authorities owed an apology to the senator.
The three Australian lawmakers that were to join Xenophon for next week’s meetings have canceled their trip in response to the deportation.
One of them, government lawmaker Steve Georganas, described the intended itinerary as normal and “very balanced,” with meetings planned with both government and opposition figures.
“It highlights that what we consider democracy here in Australia—there’s different views around the world of what that word ‘democracy’ means,” Georganas told Nine Network television on Sunday.
The fact-finding mission had not been officially endorsed by the Australian government.
Malaysia’s government says the country’s electoral system is free and fair. Officials have promised to boost transparency in this year’s elections by allowing Malaysians living overseas to cast postal ballots, lengthening campaign periods and bolstering security to prevent voter fraud.
But opposition activists say authorities have not done enough to address concerns over discrepancies in voter registration rolls, vote-buying and the use of government-controlled news media to denounce the opposition.
The upcoming elections are expected to be a close fight between Najib’s National Front coalition, which has governed Malaysia since independence from Britain in 1957, and Anwar’s three-party opposition alliance.
The National Front suffered its worst performance in 2008 elections, when it lost more than a third of the seats in Parliament amid public complaints about corruption and racial discrimination.
Associated Press writer Sean Yoong in Kuala Lumpur contributed to this report.