Hanoi Opens Three MIA Digs, Releases Letters
By Jack Jones 5 June 2012
HANOI, Vietnam—“If Dad calls, tell him I got too close to being dead but I’m OK I was real lucky. I’ll write again soon.”
That poignant message never reached the mother of Army Sgt Steve Flaherty. He was killed in Vietnam in 1969 before he could mail the letters he was carrying, including one he might have been writing when he died. The letters were taken by the Vietnamese after his death, US officials said in releasing excerpts on Monday.
The letters, chronicling the carnage and exhaustion of war, were given to Defense Secretary Leon Panetta in exchange for a Vietnamese soldier’s diary that was taken from his body by an American GI. The letters will be returned to Flaherty’s family in South Carolina.
Vietnamese Defense Minister Phung Quang Thanh and Panetta made the exchange in a ceremony in which the Vietnamese also agreed to open three new sites in the country for excavation by the United States to search for troop remains from the war. Acidic soil in Vietnam erodes bones quickly, leaving in many cases only teeth for military teams to use to try and identify service members.
Ron Ward, US casualty resolution specialist at the Joint POW/MIA Accounting Command in Hanoi, said there are at least four US troops believed to be lost in the three areas that are being opened. That leaves eight sites still restricted by the Vietnamese, he said.
Memories of the Vietnam War are fading for many Americans, and the war is the stuff of textbooks for others. But it is brought vividly alive in Sgt Flaherty’s letters. The mail from the Columbia, S.C., native to his mother, Lois, and two women identified only as Mrs. Wyatt and Betty, offer emotional accounts of his fear—and also his determination.
“I felt bullets going past me,” Flaherty writes to Betty. “I have never been so scared in my life.”
“We took in lots of casualties and death,” he writes. “We dragged more bodies of dead and wounded than I can ever want to forget.”
“Thank you for your sweet card. It made my miserable day a much better one but I don’t think I will ever forget the bloody fight we are having. … RPG rockets and machine guns really tore my rucksack.”
By 1969, the war was sharply dividing Americans back home, but Flaherty tells Mrs. Wyatt he still believes in the mission.
“This is a dirty and cruel war but I’m sure people will understand the purpose of this war even though many of us might not agree,” he writes.
In another section of the letter to his mother, Flaherty reassures her that he will get some rest.
“I definitely will take R&R,” he wrote. “I don’t care where so long as I get a rest, which I need so badly, soon. I’ll let you know exact date.”
Flaherty, who was 22 when he was killed in March 1969, was returned home for burial. Assigned to the 101st Airborne, he died in the northern section of South Vietnam.
It’s clear he saw some heavy combat.
“Our platoon started off with 35 men but winded up with 19 men when it was over,” he tells his mother. “We lost platoon leader and whole squad.”
Officials said parts of Flaherty’s letters were read in propaganda broadcasts by the Vietnamese during the war.
This is the first time such a joint exchange of war artifacts has occurred, they said.
Vietnamese Col Nguyen Phu Dat had kept Sgt Flaherty’s letters, and last August he mentioned them in an online publication.
Early this year, Robert Destatte, a retired Defense Department employee who had worked for the POW/MIA office, noticed the publication, and the Pentagon began to work to get the letters back to Flaherty’s family. Flaherty’s sister-in-law, Martha Gibbons, 73, of Irmo, S.C., said she learned of the letters’ existence about six weeks ago.
Gibbons said her husband met Flaherty when the boy was a 6-year-old living in a Japanese orphanage and her husband persuaded his mother, with whom they lived, to adopt the child. He grew up to be a well-liked, athletic boy, who dropped out of college to join the Army despite a baseball scholarship.
“He decided to enlist in the army and go fight for his country in Vietnam and he didn’t make it back,” said Kenneth L. Cannon, 80, of Prosperity, S.C., Flaherty’s uncle. “It was very hard to take. It was hard.”
Cannon said the family was told that he was in a field, taking a break to eat lunch or write letters.
“He never let us know how afraid and scared he was,” Gibbons said. “He was in danger. We knew it was bad. We just didn’t know how bad, I guess.”
She’s thrilled the information has been released.
“I had a very emotional morning all over again. But it was a wonderful emotion this time. It’s good for both countries. It’s good for all the soldiers who were killed for both countries.” Gibbons said the family would store the letters with Flaherty’s medals, scrapbook and flag.
Defense officials reviewing the packet of papers given to Panetta said it appears there are three sets of letters, including the four written by Flaherty. It was not clear how many other service members’ letters were there, but officials were going through them on Monday
The small diary belonged to Vu Dinh Doan, a Vietnamese soldier who was killed in a machine gun fight, according to defense officials. They said a Marine, Robert “Ira” Frazure of Walla Walla, Wash., saw the diary—with a photo and some money inside—on the chest of the dead soldier and took it back to the US.
The diary came to light earlier this year when the sister of a friend of Frazure’s was doing research for a book and Frazure asked her help in returning the diary. The sister, Marge Scooter, brought the diary to the PBS television program “History Detectives.”
The show then asked the Defense and State departments to help return the diary.
There are nearly 1,300 cases of troops still unaccounted for, and officers briefing Panetta said about 600 of those remains could be recoverable.
Ward said that opening the three new sites will enable the US to try to find:
—Two Air Force members who were lost when their plane was shot down in Quang Binh Province in central Vietnam in 1967.
—An Army private first class who went missing when he was out with his unit on a search-and-destroy mission in 1968 in the tri-border area of Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam.
—A Marine whose plane went down in Quang Tri Province. Another Marine on the plane ejected and was rescued.