China Says US Culpable in Japan Island Dispute

The disputed Senkaku/Diaoyutai islands in the East China Sea (Photo: Wikimedia)

BEIJING — China said on Monday that the US has “undeniable historical responsibility” in Beijing’s dispute with Japan over islands in the East China Sea, marking the second straight day that it has pinned some of the blame for the tensions on Washington.

While Beijing has not asked for outside mediation, its references to the US appear to be an attempt to prompt Washington to use its influence to soften the stance of Japan, which has steadfastly refused to hold talks over the islands, known as Diaoyu in China and Senkaku in Japan.

Japan argues that it has sovereignty over the islands and therefore there is nothing to negotiate. They were under US control between 1945 and 1972, when they were returned to Japan, which originally annexed them in 1895. China claims sovereignty over the islands, as does Taiwan.

Washington acknowledges that the islands are under Japanese administration but doesn’t take a position on who owns them. Beijing has repeatedly accused the US of emboldening Tokyo by supporting its control over the islands and stating that any conflict over them would trigger the US-Japan mutual defense pact.

“The US bears undeniable historical responsibility,” on the issue, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei said at a regular news conference Monday. “The US comments ignore facts and confuse truth with untruth. China is strongly displeased and firmly opposed to it.”

Tensions between Beijing and Tokyo soared in recent months after Japan’s government bought the islands from private Japanese owners in September.

On Sunday, another Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman strongly criticized the US over remarks by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton reiterating longstanding US policy and opposing unilateral actions that would undermine Japan’s administration of the islands.

Since September, China has repeatedly sent government patrol boats to confront Japanese coast guard ships in waters surrounding the islands and earlier this month scrambled fighter jets to tail Japanese fighters that were shadowing a Chinese patrol plane.

Such actions have raised fears that an accident or miscalculation could result in a clash. China has in its recent comments stressed the need for calm and the start of talks on the issue. Japan has also reached out, with China-friendly former Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama paying a visit last week, although it refuses to meet Chinese demands that it concede that the islands are in dispute.

In his comments, Hong said Beijing remains unswerving in its determination to assert its sovereignty, but that China and Japan were in contact on ways to ease tensions.

He urged US officials to “responsibly treat the Diaoyu issue, watch their words and deeds, maintain regional stability and Sino-US relations, so that the Chinese people can trust them.”


3 Responses to China Says US Culpable in Japan Island Dispute

  1. How do we attribute any validity to a claim from China when it invaded another nation, Tibet, without concern for Tibet’s claim of autonomy? China is heading down a dark road which can only result in eventual conflict with the world. Shame on its leaders.

  2. When China cries the whole world is culpable! I guess when the Tibetans cry they are sound bytes…get real China; you are in orbit.

  3. China, you are a big bully against weaker and smaller countries but a shrinking coward when confront with the bigger and more powerful nations like the US and Japan. They will stop you from illegally and unreasonably claiming or annexing their territories and also other nations in the nearby region. I am sure other nations too will join them to fight you and will bring you to their knees at the end. You think the world would believe you when you tell them that you are a peace loving country while claiming to almost the entire the “South China Sea” as yours? The world knows that you are good at lying and so they will unite as one congruent force to deal with you. Down China, the Most Greedy and Bully Nation on earth!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available. Comments with external links in the body text will be deleted by moderators.