Obama Criticizes Cambodia after Praising Burma
By Julie Pace 20 November 2012
PHNOM PENH, Cambodia—On a history-making trip, President Barack Obama on Monday paid the first visit by an American leader to Burma and Cambodia, two Asian countries with troubled histories, one on the mend and the other still a cause of concern.
Obama’s fast-paced, pre-Thanksgiving trip vividly illustrated the different paths the regional neighbors are taking to overcome legacies of violence, poverty and repression.
Cheered by massive flag-waving crowds, Obama offered long-isolated Burma a “hand of friendship” as it rapidly embraces democratic reforms. Hours later, he arrived in Cambodia to little fanfare, then pointedly criticized the country’s strongman leader on the issue of human rights during a tense meeting.
Obama was an early champion of Burma’s sudden transformation to civilian rule following a half-century of military dictatorship. He’s rewarded the country, officially known as Myanmar, with eased economic penalties, increased US investment and now a presidential visit, in part to show other nations the benefits of pursuing similar reforms.
“You’re taking a journey that has the potential to inspire so many people,” Obama said during a speech at the University of Rangoon.
The Cambodians are among those Obama is hoping will be motivated. White House officials said he held up Burma, a once-pariah state, as a benchmark during his private meeting on Monday evening with Prime Minister Hun Sen, the autocratic Cambodian leader who has held power for nearly 30 years. Hun Sen’s rivals have sometimes ended up in jail or in exile.
Unlike the arrangement after Obama’s meetings with Burmese President Thein Sein and democracy leader Aung Sun Suu Kyi, the US and Cambodian leaders did not speak to the press following their one-on-one talks. They did step before cameras briefly before their meeting to greet each other with a brisk handshake and little warmth.
In private, US officials said, Obama pressed Hun Sen to release political prisoners, stop land seizures and hold free and fair elections. Aides acknowledged the meeting was tense, with the Cambodian leader defending his practices, even as he professed to seek a deeper relationship with the US.
Ben Rhodes, Obama’s deputy national security adviser, said the president told Hun Sen that without reforms, Cambodia’s human rights woes would continue to be “an impediment” to that effort.
White House officials emphasized that Obama would not have visited Cambodia had it not been hosting two regional summit meetings the US attends, a rare admonishment of a country on its own soil.
The Cambodian people appeared to answer Obama’s cold shoulder in kind. Just a few small clusters of curious Cambodians gathered on the streets to watch his motorcade speed though the streets of Phnom Penh.
A welcome sign did greet Obama upon his arrival—but it heralded Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao, not the American president.
Human rights groups fear that because Obama delivered his condemnation of Hun Sen in private, government censors will keep his words from reaching the Cambodian people. And they worry the prime minister will then use Obama’s visit to justify his grip on power and weaken the will of opposition groups.
“If Hun Sen’s narrative about this visit is allowed to gel, it will create a perception that the United States and other international actors stand with Hun Sen, and not with the Cambodian people,” said John Sifton, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “It will be a tremendous blow to Cambodians who challenge his rule.”
Obama’s visit to Burma was also viewed critically by some international organizations, which saw the trip as a premature reward for a country that still holds political prisoners and has been unable to contain ethic violence.
Aware of that criticism, Obama tempered some of his praise for Burma during his six-hour visit. He underscored that the reforms that have taken hold over the past year are “just the first steps on what will be a long journey.”
Perhaps the sharpest calls for caution came from Suu Kyi, Burma’s longtime democracy champion. After meeting with Obama at the home where she spent years under house arrest, she warned that the most difficult part of the transition will be “when we think that success is in sight.”
“Then we have to be very careful that we’re not lured by the mirage of success,” Suu Kyi said, speaking with Obama by her side.
The president, winding down his first foreign trip after winning re-election, had meetings scheduled in Cambodia on Tuesday with his counterparts in the East Asia Summit. Obama has added the summit to his annual list of high-priority international meetings as he seeks to expand US influence in the region.
Obama will also meet separately on the sidelines of the summit with Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda and with Wen, the Chinese premier. It’s likely to be Obama’s last bilateral meetings with both men.
Noda dissolved his country’s Parliament last week, setting the stage for new elections his party is unlikely to win. And China is undergoing its first leadership transition in a decade, with Wen and President Hu Jintao stepping down to clear the way for new leaders in the country’s Communist Party.
Obama will return to Washington before dawn on Wednesday, in time for the ceremonial pardoning of the Thanksgiving turkey.