Hong Kong Protesters Plan March After Fruitless Talks With Government
By Donny Kwok & Diana Chan 22 October 2014
HONG KONG — Hong Kong protesters planned to march to the home of the city’s Beijing-backed leader on Wednesday to push their case for greater democracy a day after talks between student leaders and senior officials failed to break the deadlock.
Demonstrators have occupied main streets in the Chinese-controlled city for nearly a month to oppose a central government plan that would give Hong Kong people the chance to vote for their own leader in 2017 but tightly restrict the candidates to Beijing loyalists.
A wide chasm separates the protesters and the government, which has labeled their actions illegal and repeatedly said their demand for open nominations was impossible under the laws of the former British colony.
Expectations had been low for a breakthrough in Tuesday evening’s televised talks, which were cordial and pitted five of the city’s most senior officials against five tenacious but poised student leaders in black T-shirts.
Protesters were unhappy about what they felt was a lack of substantive concessions from the government officials and they dug in their heels.
Some have called for a march to the home the city’s leader, Leung Chun-ying, and will repeat their calls for him to step down.
“I am going to join the march this afternoon to express my dissatisfaction,” said Kelvin Kwan, a 29-year-old social work graduate who camped with protesters overnight in the Mong Kok district.
Andy Lau, a 19-year-old college student, said now was the time to step things up.
“I think it is time to seriously consider escalating the movement, such as expanding our occupation to many more places to pressure the government to really face and answer our demands,” he said.
Hong Kong returned from British to Chinese rule in 1997 under a “one country, two systems” formula that allows it wide-ranging autonomy and freedoms and specifies universal suffrage as an ultimate goal. But Beijing is wary about copycat demands for reform on the mainland eroding the Communist Party’s power.
City leader Leung told reporters before Tuesday’s talks that the panel that picks candidates for Hong Kong’s 2017 election could be made “more democratic.”
That was first indication of a possible concession.
“There’s room for discussion there,” said Leung, who did not take part in the talks. “There’s room to make the nominating committee more democratic.”
The end-game for the protests remains unclear. Hong Kong’s high court issued injunctions this week barring protesters from blocking roads, but the police appeared unwilling or incapable of carrying them out.
The use of tear gas by police early in the protests backfired, sparking outrage among many in Hong Kong and helping to swell the ranks of the demonstrators.
Since then, police have occasionally used pepper spray and batons but they have not tried to fully clear the streets.
The government appears to be in a quandary: unable to make concessions but wary that a crackdown would only exacerbate the protests. Analysts say the government is biding its time.
The unprecedented open debate on democracy on Tuesday night reflected a shift in the government’s approach to engage rather than shun a movement that has lasted beyond most people’s expectations.
The officials offered the prospect of discussions about how a nominating committee that will pick candidates for city leader is formed, and said they would send a report to Beijing on the situation and the protesters’ demands.
After the meeting, disappointed students said they had yet to decide whether to hold more talks.
“It is very obvious why many people are still staying here tonight,” student leader Yvonne Leung told thousands of cheering demonstrators at the tent-filled main protest site in the Admiralty district, near government offices.
“It is because we absolutely have no idea what they were talking about. … The government did not give us a concrete reply and direction in the dialogue today. We are absolutely very disappointed about this.”