Export Slowdown Threatens Emerging Asia's Economic Boom

By Stuart Grudgings 17 June 2013

KUALA LUMPUR — A deepening slump in exports is sending tremors through Asia, threatening to undermine some booming emerging economies that have surged ahead in recent years on a heady combination of easy credit, buoyant consumer demand and strong domestic investment.

Export growth throughout Asia has sagged in recent months, hit by slackening demand from the United States, Europe and China and by slumping commodity prices. Leading indicators are also pointing to weaker factory activity in the coming months.

The slowdown is being felt most keenly by Southeast Asian countries whose strong domestic economies are sucking in imports more rapidly and which now face sharp deteriorations in their trade balances that could spook investors.

Heavy stock market and currency falls in the region this week have underlined the risks as investors grow nervous that the US Federal Reserve may taper its quantitative easing (QE) policy that has fuelled a surge of credit in Southeast Asia.

“For countries like Indonesia, and to a certain extent Malaysia, you’ve had this perfect storm of weak external demand, weak commodity prices, and strong domestic demand,” said Robert Prior-Wandesforde, director of Asian Economic Research at Credit Suisse in Singapore.

“One doesn’t want to see it go too far. We don’t want these countries running into huge, unsustainable deficits because inevitably we’ll run into Asian financial crisis type stories.”

Malaysia’s trade surplus fell to its lowest level in April since the 1997 crisis with a surprise 3.3 percent year-on-year fall in exports announced last week. The country could soon run its first trade deficit in 16 years.

Exports from the Philippines, which already runs a trade deficit and last month reported the fastest annual economic growth in Asia of 7.8 percent, plunged 12.8 percent in April from a year earlier. Indonesia reported a trade deficit in April after exports contracted for a 13th straight month. Thai exports have slowed, contributing to a record trade deficit in January.

Underlining broader Asian trade weakness, China posted on Saturday its lowest export growth in almost a year in May. China’s economy has been a major source of export demand for other Asian nations, but that is expected to fade as the world’s second-largest economy begins shifting to a slower growth path.

While the US economy is showing signs of regaining traction, much of Europe remains mired in recession and China is showing worrisome signs of stumbling.

“It’s going to be the new reality for Asia. Exports will not be as exciting as they used to be,” said Euben Paracuelles, Southeast Asia economist at Nomura in Singapore.

Shrinking factory orders also point to a loss of momentum for economies whose fortunes are closely linked to China, such as Taiwan and Hong Kong. Some officials, however, played down the slowing exports, saying it did not signal a structural weakness or a persistent trend.

“What I see is a large drawdown in existing inventories on the part of our trading partners,” said Diwa Guinigundo, the deputy governor of the Philippine central bank.

“…It’s a matter of time before we see a more definitive widespread recovery of global growth and in turn, exports.”

Too Much of A Good Thing?

Robust domestic demand has been a source of strength for Southeast Asia’s emerging economies in recent years as growing spending by the middle class and a rise in infrastructure investment has reduced their traditional export dependence.

They are in a far healthier state than in 1997, having built up hefty foreign exchange reserves, reduced external debt and gained credit upgrades through improved public finances.

But worsening current account balances could still be a problem at a time when foreign funds are reducing exposure to risk and seeking safer havens. One concern in Southeast Asia is a surge in household debt in recent years. Philippine and Indonesian banks have been expanding consumer lending at an annual pace of around 20 percent, for example.

“There are certainly dark clouds hanging over a number of countries,” said Jayant Menon, a senior economist at the Asian Development Bank. “This is not talked about much but if you get a huge deterioration in capital flows, high levels of household debt could really bite.”

Nomura’s Paracuelles said Southeast Asian governments and central banks would need to respond with policy changes in coming months, tightening fiscal policy where possible and raising interest rates to protect currencies and dampen frothy domestic conditions.

The first such response came late on Tuesday when Indonesia’s central bank raised overnight interest rates to combat heavy selling pressure on the Indonesian rupiah.

Indonesia, Southeast Asia’s largest economy, looks the most vulnerable to a worsening external position, economists say, due to its dependence on commodities and slow progress on reforms.

Credit Suisse said on Wednesday it was downgrading its investment growth forecast for Indonesia this year to 5 percent from 8.6 percent, citing a sharp slowdown in capital growth.

While the slowdown should reduce overheating pressures, it said Indonesia could still struggle to fund a current account shortfall due to weak commodity prices and lingering obstacles to foreign investment in key sectors such as mining.

“A lot of Indonesian companies use profits from commodities to invest in other parts of the economy,” said Prior-Wandesforde. “The weakness in commodities could spill over into consumer spending.”