Hidden Worlds

Rev. Tang Mang of the Chin Association of Christian Communication leads a workshop session. (Photo: Lucas Stewart)

Rev. Tang Mang of the Chin Association of Christian Communication leads a workshop session. (Photo: Lucas Stewart)

HAKHA, Chin State — The road from Kalaymyo to Hakha is lined with grave markers. With little flat ground in the northern Chin Hills, cemeteries are exchanged for solitary memorials overlooking the knuckled mountain ranges. Some—usually those of the young—have photographs embedded into them; the elders are left faceless. All are etched with a name, an age, and a date of death. Yet in Chin State, as in the other six states of Myanmar, the lives of those who lived and passed away here are not recorded and remembered in the Myanmar language, but in an ethnic-minority language and literature.

I was in Chin State accompanying former political prisoner and writer Letyar Tun as part of “Hidden Words, Hidden Worlds,” a project funded by the British Council that assists in the development of creative expression in ethnic-minority languages. Twenty people—pastors, farmers, journalists and business owners, from Hakha, Kalaymyo, Thantlang, Kanggaw and Matupi townships—had gathered in Hakha to spend five days learning how to write short stories.

Among them was Sara Simon Thang, a lecturer at the Zion Baptist College in Matupi Township. Short with a wide smile, he travelled more than two days on a motorbike over mountain tracks to get to the
workshop. He was one of the few participants who could speak English.

“Our youth cannot write their own words, only Myanmar,” he said. “This is what they are taught in schools now.”

“You mean Lai Hakha?” I asked, referring to the language that our workshop was focusing on.

“No,” he answered, with a small shake of his head. “I am from Matupi. I can read and write Lai Hakha, but I mean they cannot write in Matu language.”

Silenced for over 50 years by government policies forbidding the teaching of ethnic-minority languages and the publication or distribution of literature in those languages, these literatures are among the least accessible forms of creative expression in Myanmar. That they survive at all is largely thanks to the perseverance of monastic schools in Shan and Mon states and church-based committees in Kayin, Kachin, Kayah and Chin states, where the mother tongue is taught as part of instruction in the religious literature. Secular cultural groups, often unregistered, have also played a role. Some, such as the Kachin Culture and Literature Co-operation, run annual summer camps teaching junior- and middle-school students their own language and literature.

It is these groups that the British Council collaborates with to identify ethnic-language writers to co-lead with a respected Yangon writer the seven ethnic state workshops, such as our Chin writer, Rev. Tang Mang, the literature secretary of the Chin Association for Christian Communication.

Often these writers are at the frontline of efforts to preserve their oral-storytelling traditions, publishing—despite the lack of resources and, until recently, the threat of imprisonment—texts that record their proverbs, sayings and origin myths, such as Rev. Tang Mang’s “Lai Tuanphung, Chin Folktales Vol. 1.”

However, narratives that reflect contemporary conditions are almost unheard of. And yet, it is these narratives that allow for scope and depth to raise awareness of critical social and cultural issues relevant to communities ignored for so long.

So while the “Hidden Words, Hidden Worlds” workshops focus on the technical structure of a short story—narrator, plot movement and dialogue—the instructors also guide the participants on content, on exploring emotive connections to the landscape they live in and how to interweave these themes into a literary form.

In our Kayin workshop, led by San Lin Tun and Saw Chit Than, one of the stories we discussed centered on a young man who leaves his village to work illegally on a construction site in Thailand. Separated from his family, he descends into a spiral of alcohol and drug abuse, eventually contracting AIDS. Leaving Thailand to return to his village, he is exiled by his elders. It is only after the arrival of a doctor, who educates the villagers about AIDS and teaches them that the young man is no threat to them, that he is allowed to finally return home.

In the Kachin workshop, environmental concerns, the threat of Chinese influence in the local economy and, of course, the continuing war were dominant motifs. In Hakha, poverty, exiled Chin communities and sustainable farming practices were important points of discussion.

With workshops in Kayin, Mon, Kachin, northern Shan, Chin and Kayah states already completed, and only Rakhine State left to go, the next step will be to translate the stories into Myanmar, which the participants will do themselves, and publish them in Yangon as the first collection of short stories in ethnic-minority languages.

But there is still so much more that needs to be done.

Back in Hakha, as the participants were preparing for the end-of-workshop Live Literature Night, one of them, Rev. Lang Uk, a retired pastor also from Matupi Township, but from a smaller ethnic group named the Zo Tung, pulled an unbound folio of papers out of his bag. Already an author of four Zo Tung-language hymn books, the manuscript contained his unpublished collection of writing about Zo Tung customs, rights, rituals, proverbs, sayings and legendary myths.

“Our stories haven’t been published yet,” he said, handing me the papers. “This is the first time they have been written down. Can you help me to publish?”

I looked down at the 100 pages and I really didn’t know what to say.

This story first appeared in the July 2014 edition of The Irrawaddy magazine.

4 Responses to Hidden Worlds

  1. This article is another example of the type of ANTI-BUDDHIST propaganda that the British Council terrorist group is becoming famous for in Myanmar.

    In the days when the British ruled Burma, they converted many of the hill tribes and minority ethnic groups of Myanmar to Christianity BY FORCE. Still today, as you can see very clearly, the British are ONLY interested in the stories of these ethnic groups. They are NOT interested in the living literature of the Burmese people, which is connected with Buddhism, and is not connected with primitive and violent religions imported from the West and from the Middle East.

    Does this article give any examples of the ethnic group literature the British Council are promoting? No, it does not.
    Where are the examples? Where are the extracts of poetry or of fiction? The article gives NO examples.

    Why are no examples given?

    Because the British Council is teaching these ethnic groups how to write only in the way the British want them to write. It is exactly the same as when the British Empire used to teach these exact same ethnic groups how to PRAY to an alien god. And of course, the threat of force was always waiting with a loaded gun to be fired at any poor Buddhist who dared to disagree.

    I am sure that all of us living here in Myanmar will look forward with massive excitement to the Burmese translation of the British Council’s made-up collection of regional literature from our country, although it is very difficult to say, because absolutely no examples of it have been included in this article.


  2. Why are you so suspicious?
    It is downright stupid to equate the British Council with terrorists.

    Is it better to burn the villages and rape the women, as the Myanmar Tatmadaw is doing?
    That is the practical “Buddhism” the Chin people have been confronted with.

    The seeds the military government has sown in the ethnic areas since Myanmar’s independence are yielding harvest. If they have sown weeds, the harvest is weeds.

    What about the great scarcity of food, after the blooming of bamboos created a plague of hungry rodents in Chin state, just recently? Where were the bags of free rIce for hungry Chins from the wealthy “Buddhist” cronies in Yangon and Mandalay, or even a minimum of aid for food from the central govenment?

    It is a great pity, really, because the Bamar mayority has had many chances to befriend the minorities, but they have been woefully missed.

    Christianity was seeded among the ethnics by a few foreigners during the days of colonial government. It could have become a forgotten bye-word by now, if the Myanmar Buddhists had done their duty towards the less developed minorities right after independence.
    These are precious opportunities lost, in more than half a century of time.

    The British Council is doing things in the Chin states, that were long overdue,
    Things that should have been done by the Ministery of Education of the Union of Myanmar not now, BUT YEARS AGO. –

    Instead the few Chins that managed to get a good education are pursued by mobs in the Myanmar heart lands, and attacked. (As a true event, a young Chin student was killed by a mob in central Myanmar, just because he was walking home alone after dark. Only because his uncle had government connections in Chin state, the affair was not just quickly hushed up, but it is still unclear whether the murderers were caught and punished.)

    I wonder how you can pour so much venom on the British Council for doing what the Myanmar government should have done long ago? Is it your bad conscience?

    I am a Buddhist, and I am NOT exactly pleased to find that NOW almost all educated Chins are Christians. But in fairness the lack of Right Effort by Myanmar Buddhists has to be acknowledged.

    We should acknowledge a good things, even if it is done by others. Truth is truth is truth.

  3. Hsin Pyu Gyi Gyi,

    your remarks smack of the fanaticism of Ven. Wirathu of Masoe Yein Kyaung, Mandalay, that “true son of Lord Buddha” (according to government sources; who however may not be specialists on the Buddhist scriptures):

    If you think, that the cause of Buddhism is promoted by killing innocent “infidels”, who are your neighbors; you are not following the words of Lord Buddha.

    There were monks in Lord Buddha’s days that disagreed with his teaching, while wearing the Buddhist robe. Buddha called them “mogha purisa” – deluded people.

  4. It would be good, instead of wasting energies unnnecessarily of unfounded susspicions, if the Myanmar people would not wait for the Chins and the British Council to make a translation of their stories into Myanmar.

    Educated Myanmar people should not only learn foreign languages like English, Pali, Chinese and French, but also learn to speak AT LEAST ONE of the ethnic minority languages (in addition to the Myanmar mother tongue).

    In India with its multiple languages this is fairly common.
    It is one of the peace building devices, – in addition to a friendly face and help in need, – that is available to every one at no great cost.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available. Comments with external links in the body text will be deleted by moderators.