Monywa Crackdown—Old Habits Die Hard

After seeing the violent crackdown on peaceful protesters who occupied a copper mine in central Burma, many cynics believe that we have finally seen the true colors of President Thein Sein and his “reformist” government.

The former general has been thoroughly mocked on social media, with his top peace award bestowed by the Brussels-based International Crisis Group this week particularly ripe for ridicule. One online activist published an image comparing Thein Sein to his former boss Snr-Gen Than Shwe—dubbed “monk killer” after the violent crackdown on the Buddhist clergy-led Saffron Revolution pro-democracy demonstrations in 2007.

Thursday’s pre-dawn raid left dozens of unarmed demonstrators, the majority of whom Buddhist monks, seriously injured.

Tensions at the copper mine have been rising since mid-November with protesters disrupting workers by linking arms to block the path of trucks at the construction site, and erecting camps nearby. More than 7,800 acres of land from 26 villages under the shadow of the Letpadaung mountain range have been seized to make way for the Chinese-backed project since it began last year.

Local villagers have been staging protests to demand its closure, citing environmental destruction, forced relocations and illegal land confiscation. And this is only one of many similarly controversial projects in Burma.

Several prominent activists have also visited the area to pledge support, including members of the 88 Generation Students group.

The mining project is a joint venture between the military-owned Union of Myanmar Economic Holdings Ltd (UMEH) and China’s Wan Bao Company. The association between the two firms raised alarm bells among activists who asked for the contract to be made accountable to the public.

The Chinese firm’s involvement also raised serious concerns as Wan Bao is a subsidiary of the North Industries Corporation, China’s main weapons manufacturer.

The influence of Beijing in Burma cannot be discounted and anti-China sentiment is also on the rise. As Burma opens its doors to Western investors, with the US relaxing sanctions and normalizing relations with the former pariah state, Beijing becomes more nervous.

The crackdown took place barely two weeks after US President Barack Obama made a historic visit to Rangoon during which he hailed Thein Sein’s reformist credentials.

But China is always watching.

Last week, Aung Min, a minister attached to the Burmese President’s Office, visited the area and met local people protesting the project. To the astonishment of many present, the minister publicly admitted, “We are afraid of China… If China asks for compensation, even the Myitsone Dam shutdown would cost US $3 billion.”

Beijing has long been staunch supporter of Burma’s brutal military regime and served as a lifeline by providing arms and shielding the former junta from international censure, particularly by blocking resolutions of the United Nations Security Council.

“So we don’t dare to have a row with China!” said Aung Min a few days before the crackdown. This was a sign that action was imminent. Top government officials had their minds made up to stop the protest.

Now the Burmese people are questioning who ordered the raid and why the riot police suddenly charged into the camps and viciously assaulted unarmed protesters.

The crackdown showed once again that the government, which claims to have turned over a new leaf and to listen to public opinion, is only really protecting its own interests and those of foreign investors.

Opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi, who is currently visiting Monywa, previously called for responsible investment and the government to be accountable and transparent. In reality, Thein Sein’s administration decided to side with the Burmese military’s conglomerate company UMEH and its foreign partner Wan Bao.

This ugly and brutal crackdown is an indelible black mark on Thein Sein’s ostensibly reformist government. Once again we understand that Burma’s ongoing political opening remains reversible.

One Response to Monywa Crackdown—Old Habits Die Hard

  1. It put a smile on my face when Irrawaddy wrote the title “Old Habit Die Hard”. In reality we use the word “Old Habit” only when we recognize the true changes occur and old habits come along with changes. The changes which happen at this moment are not for the betterment for the people but I see it as another way of controlling by the military and it’s corrupt business interests. I went to a town while I was visiting Burma and I saw  new section of town was built. It did not interest me the town has grown, but I was interested in how was it grown and who benifitted from it. The land that new section of town built upon does not belong to any one. The land was public own. That land was break down by the army officers in the area and sold it to the people and the officers in the area pocketed the sale. There was no public discussion, the way that handling the transition was secretive. How much more of this kind of business transection which is completely silence in public debate? There is debate going on about Myit Sone dam and copper mine, but there are many corrupt business deal going on daily through out Burma done by Military and it’s cronies. It is as usual as before. The language that military government has change, but the way of doing business is still the same. It is not old way of doing thing in new age, it is old military government and usual business deal. Why not Pyithu Hluttaw representitives declare their wealth infront of the people? Why not government start to talk about social reform in meaningful way? If we want Burma heading to the right direction, we must start to talk about meaningful changes and punish the people who are corrupt and draging the country changes to slow paste.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available. Comments with external links in the body text will be deleted by moderators.