Govt Takes Flack for Lack of Transparency on Salween Dam Plans

A stretch of the Salween River in Karenni State (Photo: Alex Ellgee / The Irrawaddy)

The fate of the Salween River in eastern Burma remains unclear, despite the government’s release of information about dams planned for the river in response to questions raised in Parliament earlier this week.

The Salween, Burma’s second largest river, is slated to see construction of six hydro-power dams in the coming years, although when exactly they will be built, and what has happened to plans for a seventh dam that was shelved in 2007, is still unknown.

On Wednesday, the deputy minister for electric power, Myint Zaw, told the Lower House that six dams would be built in partnership with foreign investors.

“All he said was that six dams would be built on the Salween to generate electricity,” said Khin Maung Yi, a Lower House MP from the opposition National Democratic Force party who represents a constituency in Rangoon’s Ahlone Township.

“I asked him about the Tasang Dam, but he didn’t answer,” he added.

The Tasang Dam, a proposed 7,110 megawatt project in southern Shan State’s Mai Tong Township, was put on hold in 2007 for unspecified reasons. The project attracted widespread criticism because of concerns about its social and environmental impact.

One reason for the government’s reticence on the issue of the dam may be the fact that opposition to projects initiated under the former military junta has grown since the current quasi-civilian government assumed power two years ago.

“As the previous projects were agreed upon for the private benefit of military-backed cronies, it seems the government doesn’t want to say too much about them,” said Win Myo Thu, chairman of the environmental NGO  Economically Progressive Ecosystem Development (EcoDev).

“If they don’t come clean, however, it will only complicate matters. What we really need in our government is someone who has the courage to really talk about these issues,” he added.

Despite this criticism, however, the government has released information about the other six dams, including the foreign investment partners—mostly Chinese and Thai companies—and how much each would generate. All are located in predominantly ethnic areas in Shan, Karenni and Karen states.

It was unclear where most of the generated electricity would go, but around 85 percent of the power that was supposed to be produced by the Thai-backed Tasang dam was slated for export to Thailand.

The fact that most of Burma’s energy resources have benefited the country’s neighbors more than its own people has long been a sore point for many Burmese, fueling opposition to megaprojects such as the Chinese-financed Myitsone dam on the Irrawaddy River, which was suspended in September 2011.

Now, however, the government is trying to sell the public on the idea of using the dams to meet domestic needs—something that some many still reject on environmental grounds.

“We can meet our own needs by building on smaller tributaries and using other sources,” said Win Myo Thu. “We should try to preserve the biggest rivers—the Irrawaddy, the Salween and the Chindwin—and keep them natural.”

5 Responses to Govt Takes Flack for Lack of Transparency on Salween Dam Plans

  1. Chinese after Chinese in all kinds of project and businesses in Myanmar! No other foreign country cannot invest in Myanmar in such important projects? World bank and Japan, or IMF or ADB? Who authorise these kind of big projects? The analysis of the impacts on social and environment must be taken before starting anything. Otherwise, another Myit Sone Dam crises would emerge. Immigration Ministry should check all illegal immigrants not only Rohingar but also seriously Chinese.

  2. “Immigration Ministry should check all illegal immigrants not only Rohingar but also seriously Chinese”
    I agree. Truth should be told and no double-standards please!

  3. “……something that some many still reject on environmental grounds.”

    Assumption must be that the reporter Nyein Nyein did not have any relative among the dead after the lovely reformist government of own people suppression for the benefit of all the foreigners opened the flood gates in Sal-daw-gyi killing people down stream.

    For that sacred ELECTRICITY which ever one WANTS but no one knows how to make it without screwing others, how many people should be killed or shooed away from their quiet, peaceful livelihood for one watt of electricity?

    Current killing of hundreds of thousands of Kachin is also partly for that ELECTRICITY as well.. Should we kill off all the millions of Kachins to use their land and waters for that SACRED ELECTRICITY? Surely the Kaya, Shan and Karen do not count except for the “leaders”. the traitors selling out the public.

  4. At least Chinese brings Job opportinites for local people and prosperity for local Economy…

    Do you think World Bank, and Japan, or IMF or ADB will act better than Chinese??? Rememeber what they did during Asian Financial Crisis…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available. Comments with external links in the body text will be deleted by moderators.