Arakan State Govt Backs Mining Projects in Strife-Torn North

Arakan, Rakhine, natural resources, mining, conflict

A view of the Arakan State coastline at the Sittwe. (Photo: Jpaing / The Irrawaddy)

A Chinese and a Luxembourg-registered firm have obtained Arakan State government approval to begin mining aluminum and titanium deposits located on beaches in the north of the state, said Arakan State Minister of Electricity and Industry Aung Than Tin.

He added that final approval from Naypyidaw for the projects, which are located in strife-torn parts of the state, was expected soon.

State government approvals were granted to a Chinese company called Shwe Shapweye (which means Gold Finder in the Burmese language) and the Luxembourg-registered Boulle Mining Group, Aung Than Tin said, adding that the firms needed to form a joint-venture with a Burmese partner.

“There is no objection from the state government to the projects,” he told The Irrawaddy, adding that the firms had “proved that the operation areas are outside of farmlands and forestry areas.”

Aung Than Tin, who until recently was state minister of mining, said the firms would mine sands for aluminum and titanium deposits at sites along the beaches of Rathedaung and Maungdaw townships.

The project sites would be located in townships where tens of thousands of people remain displaced after outbreaks of deadly inter-communal violence between Arakanese Buddhists and Rohingya Muslims last year. Maungdaw Township, a Muslim-majority area, has for many years been administered by Burmese security forces, which have been accused of committing of widespread human rights abuses against the population.

Boulle Mining Group’s website said it has mined for copper, cobalt and zinc in the war-torn Democratic Republic of the Congo, for titanium dioxide, ilmenite and zircon in Sierra Leone and for diamonds in Namibia.

A 2006 article in the Globe and Mail describes the firm’s owner Jean-Raymond Boulle as a controversial figure who “has had a long career in the diamond trade that has included brushes with rebel leaders during the civil war in the Democratic Republic of Congo and complaints about his business practices by a United Nations panel.”

The Chinese firm Shwe Shapweye has been prospecting for mineral deposits along the Ale Than Kyaw beach in Maungdaw and Angu Maw beach in Rathedaung since 2010.

A manager at Shwe Shapweye told Radio Free Asia’s Burmese-language service that mining operations on the beaches will start soon. He told the broadcaster that 1 ton of titanium could be produced by sifting through 500 tons of sand.

According to local villagers, the firm has already dug up massive amounts of sand while prospecting. The Chinese firm reportedly received security guarantees from the state government while carrying out the work.

A local civil society group, called the Wunlatt Foundation, said it was concerned over the projects’ impacts on the approximately 30 Buddhist and Muslim villages that are located on the coast near the planned mining areas.

Wunlatt Foundation member Zaw Zaw Htun said, however, that the group had been unable to inspect the situation in the project areas since inter-communal violence first broke out in June last year.

Mining of mineral-rich sands on beaches is done through open pit strip-mining. Massive amounts of sand are dug up and valuable minerals are separated in water, after which the remaining sand is dumped back onto the beach.

The practice, which is being done in countries such as the US, Australia, India and Sierra Leone, is considered environmentally harmful as it causes erosion, destroys the local ecosystem and affects wildlife on the beaches, such as sea turtles.

State Minister of Electricity and IndustryAung Than Tin claimed that local communities had already accepted the projects’ environmental consequences. “We will have to do business for our state’s development, and selling these resources is for all the people’s sake,” he added.

Kyaw Thein, the state mining minister, said he saw no problem in attracting foreign investment to the region, despite the presence of tens of thousands of refugees and allegations of widespread human rights abuses.

“The project is for the sake of local development. It would create jobs for the local people,” he said. “Although the companies would have to hire skilled workers from abroad, the manual laborers will be from the villages.”

Soe Nyein, a state lawmaker from Kyauk Taw Township, said he was concerned about the decision to grant mining licenses, as it had not been discussed with Arakan parliamentarians or with local communities.

“These sands are very valuable, the government should be transparent about it, and consult with the locals first about whatever they do,” he said.

Soe Nyein said that under Burma’s military-drafted 2008 Constitution state governments are largely under direct control of the central government in Naypyidaw, which has often pushed through natural resource extraction projects in ethnic regions at the expense of local communities and the environment.

“It is important to think of the advantages for our local people and benefits for our state, and not have it be like projects such as the Shwe gas pipeline,” he said, referring to the Chinese-owned project that pumps Burmese gas from the Arakan coast to southwestern China.

6 Responses to Arakan State Govt Backs Mining Projects in Strife-Torn North

  1. So that’s what you get from your great leaders, dear Arakanese – the opportunity to become manual labourers in a ruined environment. In your spare time, if you can afford any, they’ll keep you distracted and divided with racism and lies.

  2. “State Minister of Electricity and Industry Aung Than Tin claimed that local communities had already accepted the projects’ environmental consequences. “We will have to do business for our state’s development, and selling these resources is for all the people’s sake,” he added.”

    But is that right? How does the minister get the approval of the local population? Is there a recorded document, with video evidence and all? Are you sure it is done on the people’s sake nof for the ministry’s or local government’s economic prospects?
    If approval is to be proven, the mining and beneficiation methods must be such as to refill and re-terrace the dug-up holes to agree with the original beach landscape, taking away as little sand as practicable. The grade is as is in the article only 0.5%. They can’t take away 20% of the sand in the landscape. Besides, the beneficiation method must not pollute the beaches and the sea waters there with chemicals used in the process.

  3. Sorry. Let me correct myself. The grade of the ore is not o.5%. It is 0.2%.

  4. I very much doubted their qualifications for administration of the strfe-torned poorest state in Burma who are just thinking about selling out everthing while people are deep in poverty and abject conditions.

  5. How about the mine`s life? 30 years or 50 years?The sediment from mining operation will kill slowly to the reefs along the coast.

  6. 0.2% grade of ore? Still the mining is feasible? Well, State Minister of Electricity and Industry Aung Than Tin, are you kidding with the environment and the disaster of the Kaladan and Mayu Rivers’ ecosystem? Don’t take it for granted that Arakan State’s loss is not Burma’s loss, or Burma’s gain. Or else you should not have uttered these words. What are the hazards involved in the mining process – short term and long term affects on the environment? Will the area not suffer from river erosion, and total vanishing of tracts of wild and inhabited lands because of the negative impacts of the open-pit mining? Have you done the feasibility study and published it for the people to see? What transparency has your government followed in granting the mining rights, and also engaging into a deal? For one thing the oppressed Rakhine and Rohingya will now rise together in insurgency for all your stupidity. Thank you, Minister, for all your intelligent efforts, Burma will now face real disintegration. At that moment please don’t blame the Rakhine Rohingya nexus, it is your stupid parliamentarian and government’s nexus that will bring independence to Arakan, at the cost of Burma’s disintegration as it happened to USSR. Though neither the Rohingyas nor the Rakhines understand now how devastating the environmental consequences will be, time will come in a short while when everything goes into jeopardy and these two not-so-intelligent communities will wake up to a harsh morning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available. Comments with external links in the body text will be deleted by moderators.